Today's paper: 83 stories · 395 sources

Every story, told six ways. You pick the side.

· Today's paper

Ongoing storyline

El-Sayed family ties scrutiny

Get a notification when this storyline has a new story.

What's happening

Republican Mike Rogers and Democrat Abdul El-Sayed met in their second and final Michigan Senate debate in Detroit, where Rogers said El-Sayed has ties to the Muslim Brotherhood and asked whether he is for America or terrorist groups overseas.(source: Oct 21: Rogers and El-Sayed clash in final Michigan Senate debate)

How we got here

  1. On NBC's Meet the Press, Kristen Welker asked Abdul El-Sayed whether he or his family had ties to the Muslim Brotherhood, and El-Sayed answered no.(source: Oct 12: El-Sayed denies family Muslim Brotherhood ties as sister's posts surface)
  2. El-Sayed's half-sister Eman Abdelhadi wrote in a 2012 post about their mother's activism in the Muslim Brotherhood in the early 1970s while in college, and also wrote in 2012 that her family has long been MB and in 2013 asked for prayers for family members supporting the MB in Egypt.(source: Oct 12: El-Sayed denies family Muslim Brotherhood ties as sister's posts surface)
  3. Their mother, Fatten Elkomy, attended Alexandria University, which a Brookings Institution report described as having strong Muslim Brotherhood activity in the 1970s, and El-Sayed suggested his Republican opponent, Mike Rogers, was floating Islamophobic attacks against him and his family.(source: Oct 12: El-Sayed denies family Muslim Brotherhood ties as sister's posts surface)
  4. El-Sayed confirmed that his sister-in-law, Mariam Jukaku, was on the federal terrorist watchlist and was a plaintiff in a 2016 lawsuit challenging her placement on the list, and he is scheduled to campaign with former President Barack Obama.(source: Oct 18: El-Sayed Confirms Sister-in-Law Was on Terrorist Watchlist)
  5. At the final debate, Rogers said El-Sayed signed a 2012 open letter urging an Egyptian politician to purge the media and police.(source: Oct 21: Rogers and El-Sayed clash in final Michigan Senate debate)

Summary of our earlier coverage: every sentence links to the stories it comes from, numbered as in the timeline below.

Timeline

Oldest first

How each side's framing changed

Each side's frame, story by story
Side1El-Sayed denies family Muslim Brotherhood ties as sister's posts surface2El-Sayed Confirms Sister-in-Law Was on Terrorist Watchlist3Rogers and El-Sayed clash in final Michigan Senate debate
Conspiracy leftNo coverageNo coverageNo coverage
Far leftNo coverageNo coverageNo coverage
LeftNo coverageNo coverageNo coverage
RightSays sister's posts contradict El-Sayed denialWashington Free BeaconSays El-Sayed defended sister-in-law on watchlistFox News (Politics)Calls El-Sayed a national security riskNew York Post (Politics)
Far rightCalls El-Sayed denial contradicted by sister's postsTheBlazeCalls El-Sayed's watchlist admission a problemBreitbart (Politics)Says El-Sayed must answer on terrorist tiesBreitbart (Politics)
Conspiracy rightNo coverageNo coverageNo coverage
ReadersReaders: no picks yetReaders: no picks yetReaders: no picks yet

Debate questions over time

  1. Should voters weigh a candidate's family ties to a group when deciding how to vote?

    Join the debate on El-Sayed denies family Muslim Brotherhood ties as sister's posts surface
  2. Should the federal terrorist watchlist be reformed?

    Join the debate on El-Sayed Confirms Sister-in-Law Was on Terrorist Watchlist
  3. Should voters weigh candidates' alleged ties to foreign groups when deciding a Senate race?

    Join the debate on Rogers and El-Sayed clash in final Michigan Senate debate